With the quarter at a close and the reveal of their 9 week grades, students are finally seeing how the parts of their efforts in art add up. As we have gone through the previous weeks, I have tried to make sure students understood the make-up of their grade; how many points things were worth, how one mistake on one project would not be their downfall, how not turning in a project at all might be, and how to make sure they were growing on their rubric. However, it isn’t until they see that first report card that things kind of all come together. I would like to work toward that happening more when it comes to individual projects as well, but for now, the report card is the ultimate showing of their hard work or lack-there-of. This is the first year that I have had students tracking their progress in personal trackers (see the post Diagnostics and Tracking for details) and it is proving to be very useful in student understanding of growth and data. However, there is always room for improvement and I hope this system continues to expand in detail and frequency so students are consistently invested in their grades and growth as artists. I want them to be recording their daily participation points – perhaps in some kind of exit activity – and figuring out how to have them track mastery of objectives and/or elements along the way. I will be brainstorming this for the coming semester so any ideas are very welcome! The more urgent issue however, is once in a while, I still have students ask “Ms. Bradshaw why did you give me a C on this!?!?” rather than understanding clearly how the rubric works and being invested in the fact that they earn their grades and I am merely there to record them and point them in the direction of growth. In order to move closer to that I think 3 things need to be done:
1. Students need to more clearly understand and be invested in the rubric. I think this will come with repetition, review, and by breaking down and focusing on rubric rows. Every time we do a project we need to go over the rubric before and after. I think I will have them choose which rubric row will accompany our challenge each unit to up the critical thinking skills we are focusing on this year.
2. Students need to better understand the classroom expectations for independent projects. This will be helped by the rubric review pre-project and break down of rubric rows so expectations can be layed out for each category. I think also encouraging students to move beyond the “scribble stage” in studios would contribute to growth in this area. Students created great plans for projects at the beginning of this unit but I would say only about 15% of students stuck with their plan in any way. I need to figure out a way to promote problem solving in order to create their way-cool ideas rather than making another gun out of toilet paper rolls because the kid next to them did and it looked kind of cool. I had way too many last minute projects turned in this time around.
3. Students need to feel ownership of their projects and effort and operate with a growth mindset. The final piece comes down to investment. If students are invested in their work and take ownership of it, they are more likely to see themselves as earning their grade rather than me giving it to them. I need to impart on them a drive and value of hard work so that students are turning in their best work rather than a last minute piece just to have something in. Students should be focused on getting better with each piece rather than seeing them all as separate entities.
This is far from a perfect (or complete) plan but I think if I am mindful of these three components and work toward improving them, students’ personal investment in their grades will increase. I want to continue to improve the quality of student data tracking and the consistency in which we track. When students become comfortable with the process, it allows for deeper conversation about why and how this can help them in both art class and how this can be transferred to other aspects of their school career and lives. Hopefully…